GREENVILLE, SOUTH CAROLINA | I contributed research and writing to this episode, which took place on the night of April 1990. The next morning, a 28 year old woman didn’t show up for work. Nobody had heard from her in almost 36 hours. When maintenance finally opened her apartment door, water was still running in the tub and it had overflowed into the apt. Her name was Genevieve, but everyone called her Jenny. Originally from Youngstown, Ohio, she had moved to South Carolina less than two years earlier and built an entire life there from scratch. Her case went cold. However, 16 years later, and 600 miles away, investigators in Portageville, Missouri, finally developed a full DNA profile in the 1998 murders of 38-year-old Sherri Scherer and her 12-year-old daughter Megan, who were killed inside their own farmhouse in a 40 minute window while the rest of the family was stuck behind a truck blocking the only road home. Missouri had spent eight years with evidence they couldn’t use. When they finally entered that profile into the national database, it came back to an apartment in South Carolina. Two unsolved cases became one unsolved case. And there was still no name.
Like this video? Watch more from Kimbyrleigha.
